Syncing Bookmarks And Favorites With Firefox 4 And Chrome 10

bookmarksync

Previously:
Battle Of The Browser Updates
Comparing The New Internet Browsers, aka Microsoft And The LastPass Problem

Many people are building imposing lists of bookmarked web sites. Having access to that list from each of our computers is quickly moving from a convenience to a necessity.

The new browsers each take a crack at supplying a tool to sync your favorites from one computer to another. There is no shortage of third party apps to do the same chore, so these are by no means your only options. They do, however, provide another glimpse at the way the developers of each browser handled a simple task.


chromelogo

Google Chrome 10 demonstrates what happens when Google’s quest for simplicity goes well.

Turn on Sync in Chrome by pushing a button under Options / Personal Stuff and supplying the email address and password for your Google Account.

You’re done. An encrypted copy of your bookmarks, passwords and autofill entries, browser preferences, themes, and web apps is quietly sent online.

When you hit Sync on a second computer and log into the same account, all of that information is synced with the second computer. If you’ve already been using the second computer for a while, the system asks permission to merge the bookmarks and settings, and does its best not to create duplicates and to handle conflicts gracefully. Changes are synced almost immediately.

It is, roughly, exactly the way you would expect this to work.

Google’s instructions add an interesting warning.

Be careful if you share your browser with multiple people. If someone signs in to the sync feature with his or her Google Account on your computer, your settings on that computer will be added to the Google Account.

See how that works? You log into your computer, then hand it to someone who wants to steal things from you. That person syncs your settings in Chrome to their Google account – including your saved passwords. Don’t do that, okay? (It’s not an issue for LastPass users, who can and should turn off the feature in Chrome that memorizes passwords.)


firefoxlogo

Firefox 4 shows us how to implement the same thing very badly.

It’s easy to create a “Firefox Sync Account.” It’s just your email address and, yes, sigh, another password. That’s it! You’re set up to sync your bookmarks, browsing history, passwords saved by Firefox, and more.

firefox4sync

Go to the second computer and hit the Firefox Sync button and log in with the same address and password and . . . what’s that you say? The “Sync Key”? Hmm. Here are the instructions:

Part 2: How to connect your other computer to your Sync account

[Enter your email address and password, then:]

“Enter your Sync Key and then click Next.

“Your Sync Key is a long series of characters that was created for you when you set up your Sync account. You can find it by following the instructions in Where can I find my Firefox Sync Key?

The answer to the question, “Where can you find your Firefox Sync Key?” is: on the first computer. Okay, back to the first computer, back to the Sync settings.

firefox4synckey

That’s a 26-character alphanumeric string. You’ll be typing it into the second computer to turn on Firefox Sync. Seriously.

But there’s more.

If something goes sideways – your computer dies or you reformat the drive – you can always generate a new Sync Key if you somehow misplaced the original 26-character alphanumeric string. (Unforgivable. I keep mine in the nightstand by my bed, along with the Microsoft license codes.)

Guess what happens when you generate a new Sync Key on your rebuilt computer? Right! You immediately wipe out all the saved information online and nothing is synced to your new computer!

Wait – that’s not what you guessed?

It’s clumsy and ugly. I assume it works, but I’m not sure I’ll ever bother to find out.

Tomorrow: Syncing Bookmarks And Favorites With Internet Explorer 9 And XMarks